Sharper Thinking

Critical-Thinking · November 10, 2026

Correlation Isn't Causation (and the Missing Third Thing)

Two things moving together doesn't mean one causes the other. Often a third thing is quietly driving both.

When Two Things Rise Together

Ice cream sales and sunburn both climb in summer, but neither causes the other: the weather drives both. That hidden third factor is called a confounder, and it sits behind many claims that sound convincing, like 'people who do X are healthier' or 'teams that use Y perform better'.

Questions to Ask Before You Believe the Link

  • Could the cause run the other way round?
  • Is there a third thing that could be driving both?
  • Could it be coincidence, especially with a small sample?

Hold the Claim Lightly

A scientist's first move isn't to reject the connection. It's to ask what else could explain it.